Shaken faith in our medical system.


So Chey was looking around for a new doctor.  She went online to her insurance company’s website, and looked for the doctor nearest to us that was associated with her insurance.  She found a guy close to home here in Edgewater, and made an appointment.  So far, so good.

She started feeling a bit uneasy when she entered the office though.  There was a lot of religious stuff around. 
You know, bible quotes on the wall, a bible laying on the table, that kind of thing.  Before you get all up in arms, yes, I know there are plenty of good doctors out there who are also religious.  I’d just prefer that my doctor not rely on miracles to keep me healthy.  But, this was only the tip of the iceberg.

Chey went back into the exam room, waiting for the doctor to show up.  He walks in the room, and with barely a glance at Chey, starts writing a prescription for M2HCG. Ok, never heard of this stuff.  Well, he says that you put three drops of this stuff under your tongue everyday, and you will lose 100 pounds in a month.  One hundred pounds.  In a month.  Oh, and to make this work, the patient must also stick to a diet of less than 500 calories a day of mostly raw vegetables.  Now the bullshit alarms are really going off.  Chey says loosing that much weight that fast sounds unhealthy.  This guy assures her that it works, and offers some testimonials of others who have tried this stuff.  Testimonials, not medical studies.  Red flag number 3.   

Well, he writes Chey a prescription for this M2HCG stuff.  Chey also asked for some sleeping pills, as she’s had a hard time falling asleep lately.  After a speech about how he’s not a drug dealer, he gives Chey a prescription for that as well.  Chey leaves with a form to go get some blood work done at a lab as well.

After we both got home from work that evening, we did some poking around on the ol’ internet.  There are some skeptic sites that I check regularly, including a few concerning medical woo.  It turns out this HCG drops stuff is actually a homeopathic “remedy”.  Wikipedia has a pretty good explanation of what homeopathy is, but basically it’s a belief that extremely dilute concentrations of active substances can cure symptoms caused by those substances.  If arsenic makes you sick, a homeopath will proscribe you arsenic, but diluted so many times with water that there is no remaining arsenic in the “remedy” he gives you.  It’s medical woo of the highest order. 

And it turns out that the FDA regards the use of HCG in homeopathic remedies for weight-loss to be fraudulent, according to this article in USAToday.  Apparently, because no one is actually harmed from taking this stuff (its plain water after all) the FDA hasn’t put much in the way of resources into tracking down these criminals. 

But WTF is an M.D. doing prescribing this shit?  What can you do when you come across something like this?  I mean it’s one thing to read about stories like this on the internet, but this is my wife here.  This quack is just down the road from my house.  How many people rely on this wacko for health advice and treatment, when he’s selling them a load of BS?  Has anyone else come across this kind of stupidity out there? Should we actually try to do something about this?  I mean he hasn’t hurt us in any way, but it just seems wrong.

In happier news, Chey then went instead to the doctor’s office I use.  She had a nice sit down with an RN and a PA, got her questions answered, and was given the help she was looking for.  Like actual medical advice, not superstitious nonsense.

Advertisements

8 Comments

Filed under Uncategorized

8 responses to “Shaken faith in our medical system.

  1. bad touch

    maybe it’s time to give that doctor some BAD TOUCH

    YEAH YEAH

    BAD TOUCH

    IN THE TRAIN

    but with all due seriousness, I think a call to the medical malpractice board is in order. If you just let it go by whining on the internet… then it’s just going to go on. It makes you feel better, but doesn’t solve anything.

    Meanwhile, get back to administering some BAD TOUCH

    BAD TOUCH YEAH

    PENIS LOL

  2. Pingback: Yet more woo intruding upon my life « Grasping Blindly in the Dark

  3. Matt G

    What a bunch of bullshit – man I was pissed when I read this. If it were me I would march down there with my guns loaded, evidence in hand, and call him out on how this placebo-effect medication makes me feel. Sounds like your classic way for people to make money and try to take advantage of people’s budget and morals.

    Realistically, however, I would inform someone of the problem. From the research I gathered (http://www.krattorneysmalpractice.com/CM/Custom/Firm-Overview.asp), this would fall under a prescription error, and a lawyer will usually only take a medical malpractice case in this situation if the victim is subject to surgical error or wrongful death. Not to sure what your chances are but maybe you could dig deeper and somehow strip this douchebag out of his doctorate degree.

  4. Scott

    I’d bet the BBB would like to hear about it, and the Florida Board of Medicine. http://www.doh.state.fl.us/mqa/enforcement/enforce_home.html

  5. Pingback: Update on that homeopathic quack. « Grasping Blindly in the Dark

  6. Anonymous

    I lost 35 pounds in 38 days on this stuff just this October. The stuff works and he’s helped many whith real chronic weight problems. So be fore you go getting on your high horse check the facts.

    • When one goes to a doctor looking for help with problems sleeping, and the “doctor” instead prescribes placebos to make you loose weight, without addressing why one came to the doctor in the first place, that’s a problem.

      As to the claim that placebo pills can make you loose a lot of weight fast, I would love to see any respectable medical practitioner tell me that crash dieting is anything other than horrible for you. Loosing weight and keeping it off is hard, there are no magic pills that will do it for you, especially not pills “The Establishment” is keeping hidden as part of some vast conspiracy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s